Baby Gates

Best Baby Gates for Fireplaces with Heat-Resistant Materials

Sandra W Bullock

This website is reader-supported. When you click on links, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

One of the most serious hazards that your baby can encounter in your home is the fireplace. While it may seem like an obvious thing to secure your with a safety barrier to the fireplace, a survey conducted by Safe Kids Worldwide found that nearly 60 percent of parents with children younger than five don’t have any type of barrier blocking access to their fireplace.

As a curious parent with a keen interest in baby safety, I delved deeper into the topic of fire hazards and safety measures. During my research, I stumbled upon alarming statistics that sent shivers down my spine. In the year 2020 alone, Safe Kids’ statistics revealed a staggering 61,526 emergency room-treated injuries and 9,361 hospitalizations resulting from fire accidents, tragically leading to 228 fatalities. Shockingly, 43% of these fatalities involved children under the age of 4.

Below is a snapshot from the Safe Kids flier;

Snapshot showing baby ER injuries and fatalities from fire in 2020

It’s crystal clear from these stats that infants and kids are the fire accident magnets. Their insatiable curiosity leads them straight to the flames, with no clue about self-saving techniques. Guess they missed the memo on Fire Safety 101!

Not to downplay the seriousness of the matter but the 60% figure representing parents who don’t bother to install fireplace safety gates contributes significantly to these figures. I hope more awareness of this crucial aspect of baby-proofing will spark the urgency to keep our little ones safe.

Moving on, let’s talk about the best baby gates for fireplaces.

Similar to other baby gates that have been deemed unsafe, such as single-panel freestanding gates, some fireplace gates can pose a hazard rather than enhance safety, depending on their design and safety features.

Which features make a baby gate great for a fireplace?

  • Fire and heat resistance materials: Due to the potential presence of sparks, embers or sudden heat blasts due to fireplace use nearby, a fire-resistant gate is an absolute must.
  • Sturdy and stable design: A sturdy baby gate can withstand any slams, bumps or knocks from your child or the occasional adult leaning on it.
  • Childproof lock mechanism: No-brainer, this one. A childproof lock keeps the gate from unlatching when your kid is trying to push or pull it open.
  • Non-toxic materials: For a crawling or teething baby, it’s imperative that the gate material not only be safe under fire but also non-toxic for consumption (because you know they will try!).
  • Easy to install: The easier it is to set up the gate, the less frustrated you’ll be and the more time you’ll have to keep an eye on your little one.

How we ranked the top brands in our list:

  1. A safety certification – As a rule of thumb, consider gates approved by the Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association (JPMA). These gates are independently tested to meet the required 10 safety standards including the latest safety standard included in 2021. Read all the baby safety gates standards here.
  2. Locking mechanism: We gave extra points for gates with dual-action locking mechanisms that require more than one step to open, making it difficult for a child to figure out.
  3. Materials used: Gates made from safe and durable materials such as steel or mesh received higher rankings.
  4. Ease of installation: Gates that have an easy installation process – regardless of whether drilling or no drilling is involved were given a higher score.
  5. Type of gate: We favored hardware-mounted gates over pressure-mounted ones. Hardware-mounted gates are more secure and can withstand the pulling and pushing of a toddler better than pressure-mounted gates. Check out secure hardware-mounted gates here.
  6. Customer reviews: We went through hundreds of customer reviews to get real-world feedback on each gate’s performance, safety features, durability, and ease of use.
  7. Our observations: We also managed to get a hold of a few brands that we used with our babies, to see how well they perform in real-life scenarios. Versatile brands that are portable, with wide adjustable widths and can be used both indoors and outdoors faired well. Although fireplaces are mostly indoors, versatile brands made it easy to use the gates in more than one location.

Overall Best Baby Gate for Fireplace:

Regalo Super Wide Adjustable Baby Gate

Of the 7 factors we used to rank fireplace baby gates, Regalo Super Wide Adjustable Baby Gate emerged top with a clear distinctive win as the overall best baby gate for a fireplace. This all-steel-design gate is super versatile and can convert into a super wide gate or an 8-panel playard making an enclosure with 192 inches. And that’s not all.

The safety locking features of this Regalo gate also make it stand out and it is Certified to both JPMA and ASTM standards. To ensure stability and to meet the CPSC’s safety standards for gates, this safety gate can also be mounted with 2″ wall mounting brackets on each side.

There is just one significant precaution. With steel frame side panels, exposure to the fire can make the panels heat up and can increase the risk of burns. It’s important to note that baby gates are NOT FIRE BARRIERs and should only be used to keep your child away from the fireplace for a limited time.

Upon recognizing the inherent burn hazards associated with this gate, I came up with 2 mitigating solutions that you may consider implementing.

Given that the gate is super wide, you need to ensure that you mount the gate further from the fireplace so that the child cannot reach the gate’s panels.

In addition, you can also consider using a fireplace screen with steel mesh in conjunction with this baby gate for added safety.

Overall, with its versatility and safety features, the Regalo Super Wide Adjustable Baby Gate is our top recommendation for a fireplace baby gate.

The Safest Fireplace Baby Gate

Toddleroo by North States Extra Wide Baby Gate:

If you’re concerned about the heat and burn risks associated with Regalo’s steel baby gate, we recommend considering the Toddleroo by the North States Extra Wide Baby Gate. Crafted from natural wood and designed with secure hardware mounting, this fireplace baby gate offers the utmost safety.

This JPMA-certified gate is made from sustainable natural wood material sourced from here in the US. By getting this gate, you will not only be contributing to the sustainability of the environment but will also boost your home decor with its natural wood finish. One of my commitments this past year was to go full-scale sustainable products and wasn’t even aware that this brand is made from locally sourced wood.

The wood is more important for safety, however, than perhaps it is a sustainable material. Unlike steel, wood does not conduct heat effectively. And so, this gate is ideal for use around fireplaces or other sources of extreme heat.

In addition to its material composition, the Toddleroo baby gate also boasts an extra wide design perfect for covering large fireplace openings. It can also be easily extended to fit wider areas from 60″ to 103″ wide.

Not much to say about this product. It has checked my key safety features including hardware mounting that ensures it’s firmly in place to prevent toppling over. It is also made from heat-resistant material and is both JPMA-certified and sustainable-sourced here in the US.

All those makes me happy and hope you can consider this brand too if you want a safer option than Regalo above.

Reviews of Other Best Fireplace Baby Gates in 2024

Bonnlo 121-inch Wide Safety Gate

This safety gate made it to our list for being among the finest metal baby gates for fireplaces on the market. The baby gate consists of 5 panels with a solid construction that spreads 121-inch wide. That makes it a good barrier for your fireplace even if it has an angled opening. It stands 31 inches high which is tall enough to block any baby.

We liked the steel frame that is strong enough to withstand your little one’s bumping strength to keep him or her safe. Even better, there are metal mounting brackets if you need to screw the gate into the wall. The wall attachments are flexible to make it easy for you to affix the baby gate to the wall at an angle.

Other than the configurability that allows you to install the Bonnlo safety gate into any shape that fits your fireplace opening, you can add 3 more panels. These separately bought panels will help you customize your space. The design has a walk-through door plus a safety locking feature.

KidCo G3111 Hearth Gate

KidCo was among the first companies to introduce metal child safety gates in the US about 28 years ago. Its G3111 made it to our list today as one of the best fireplace baby gates for your standard 6-inch hearth. It has a width of 128 inches and a height of 29.5 inches.

To keep your little one safe, the G3111 hearth gate is made using robust tubular steel with robotic welding. Add nylon-based plastic parts with fiberglass reinforcement and you get solidity, durability, and longevity. We loved the unique magnet-lock tech that makes the 2-way walk-through door self-closing. This makes it hard for your baby to open access to the fireplace.

While this hearth gate is easy to install and assemble, it is not as sturdy since some buyers have complained about 1 and 2-year-old pushing it and breaking it.

What to Consider when Choosing Top Baby Gates Brands for Babyproofing the Hearth:

Get hardware-mounted models:

Babies are curious and will want to test their strength by pushing and climbing on any gates you have around the house. For this reason, it’s important to find a sturdier gate that is hardware-mounted so they cannot access dangerous areas like the fireplace or stove. Pressure-mounted gates do not provide enough safety for fireplaces, so avoid using them altogether.

Get a baby gate with a gate that your baby can’t open:

Another important factor to look for is a gate that your baby cannot open on their own. Many models on the market come with a locking mechanism, so be sure to find one that will keep your little one safe and sound.

Get a baby gate that fits your fireplace hearth:

You’ll also want to make sure that the baby gate you select is the right size for your fireplace. There are many different sizes and shapes of fireplaces, so it’s important to measure the opening before making your purchase. This will ensure that you get a perfect fit and that your baby cannot squeeze through any gaps.

Get a baby gate with a sturdy construction:

When it comes to safety, you can never be too careful. That’s why it’s important to find a baby gate that is made from high-quality materials. Avoid any gates that are made from flimsy plastic or metal as they can easily be broken or bent. Instead, opt for a sturdier gate that is built to last.

Wood vs gas-burning fireplace

If you choose to get a wood-burning fireplace, your baby gate should be at least five feet away from the fire to prevent embers or sparks from burning your baby. When using a gas fireplace, the baby gate can be slightly closer, but heat and little fingers getting too close should still be considered.

Insist on safety-certified brands:

A JPMA-certified hearth gate is a good place to start. This indicates that it has satisfied all worldwide voluntary safety standards as well as those mandated by law. Look for a label on the gate that states it has been tested for high security.

Avoid plastic gates or playpens as makeshift gates:

Plastic gates are not safe for use around fireplaces as they can easily be melted or warped by heat.

A playpen might seem like a good idea to use as a baby gate, but it’s actually very dangerous. The sides are not tall enough to keep your baby from crawling over, and the mesh can easily be climbed.

Can Electric fireplaces be a good alternative to baby gates:

Electric fireplaces provide all the benefits of a real fireplace – without any of the dangers. They’re much safer for homes with young children, and are easy to install. Homeowners also love that electric fireplaces provide extra heat. Unlike wood or gas-powered fireplaces, electric models don’t produce any harmful emissions – just some fake flames.

Below is an image of one of the top electric fireplace brand called R.W Electric Fireplace selling for over $250 on Amazon.

R.W Electric Fireplace - Alternative for regular wood and gas-powered fireplace
R.W Electric Fireplace – Alternative for regular wood and a gas-powered fireplace

This electric fireplace by R.W.FLAME is ETL Certificate Approved and has a safety auto-heat kill feature to avoid overheating. The heat is good for maintaining the natural humidity within the air without making the room too dry.

This fireplace also has a touch screen and remote control, 12 flame & LED flame bed color modes, 5 flame speed modes, 5 flame brightness levels, and an automatic flame design that changes the color and brightness of the flames automatically. There is also an energy-saving mode that adjusts the wattage depending on whether you want warmth or just enjoy the visual of the flames.

It doesn’t require a chimney:

Another great thing about electric fireplaces is that they don’t require a chimney. This means that you can install them just about anywhere in your home – even in a room that doesn’t have an existing fireplace.

If you’re looking for a more permanent solution, an electric fireplace insert is a great option. These inserts fit into your existing fireplace, and can be used with or without the heater turned on. Many inserts come with a remote control, so you can easily adjust the temperature from anywhere in the room.

Check out our comprehensive baby gates buying guide that we recently updated.

Where to buy

Are you living in Canada, the US, the UK, or any other place in the world? You can check the variety of baby gates around the fireplace on Amazon using the links we provided. They are also available on other online stores such as eBay, Walmart, and more.